Holiday from hell
Lynnette Hoffman
The Australian
September 25, 2004
THERE were a few possible
reasons for the severe, incapacitating stomach cramps that forced
University of Wollongong PhD student Rachel Przeslawski into a doctor's
office in London last year with complaints that "aliens" had invaded her
stomach and caused two days of excruciating pain.
Was it drinking tap water in rural Malaysia? The chicken simmering away
all day in big pots at the hawker stalls that she'd readily consumed?
Swimming with elephants in a murky creek?
She's still not sure. The symptoms subsided after
a few hellish days and allowed her to get on with her trip. Considering
that Przeslawski hadn't consulted a doctor before travelling and was not
vaccinated against hepatitis A or B or typhoid, things could have turned
worse. Stupid, she concedes, but the fact is Przeslawski is far from
unique.
Late last year a Newspoll survey on behalf of the
pharmaceutical company Aventis Pasteur found nearly 60 per cent of
travellers do not receive vaccinations for preventable diseases before
they travelled to exotic destinations. Another study, by the Travel
Health Advisory Group (THAG), found more than 50 per cent of the 500
Australian travellers surveyed did not seek any health advice before
travelling.
"We do these surveys almost annually, and in the
last six years the figures have remained constant," says Dr Bernie
Hudson, microbiologist and infectious disease physician at the Royal
North Shore Hospital in Sydney and chair of THAG. "People think they're
not at risk, and they are, even if they are going to be in developed
countries."
Think SARS, influenza, rabies. And while hepatitis
A is most common in the developing world, western countries are not
immune – Belgium had an outbreak of more than 200 cases in July and
August.
When it comes to smart travel, Hudson says Swiss
travellers lead the pack as the most proactive regarding their health.
Australians rank about the same as North Americans, and UK travellers
lag behind the lot.
Given that activities as simple as sipping a drink
chilled with ice or brushing your teeth with water from a sink, as
tempting as downing a meal from a street vendor or as seemingly
innocuous (or unavoidable) as using a public restroom can put a
traveller in contact with diseases like typhoid and hepatitis A, it's
not surprising the Newspoll survey found 98 per cent of unvaccinated
travellers had done at least one thing that would have put them at risk
of contracting such diseases.
Almost 50 per cent of people experience some
health problem during their travel to a developing country and about 8
per cent seek medical attention either while they're still travelling or
once they arrive back, according to The Text Book of Travel Medicine
and Health, published in 1999.
Diarrhoea is the most common health problem
travellers to the developing world face, and it can be more than just a
source of discomfort, especially in young children, because it can cause
severe dehydration.
The vaccine-preventable disease you're most likely
to pick up overseas is hepatitis A. Staff at the Matraville Travel
Clinic Australia (part of the Matraville Medical Complex in Sydney's
eastern suburbs) have seen their fair share of returned travellers with
such cases. And it's not a pretty sight.
"You can be off work from anywhere from a few
weeks to six months," says Dr Jerry Schwartz, the clinic's medical
director.
Schwartz says the problems are amplified in young
children and the elderly, and can even be fatal. The disease attacks the
liver and can cause unsightly symptoms like jaundice, but just as
disturbingly, some people contract the disease and show no symptoms at
all. That means they may be spreading it without even realising it,
which was probably the case for one elderly woman in her 80s who came
into the practice and was diagnosed with the illness despite not having
travelled overseas. She had been in contact with a young traveller and
might have contracted it from him. It took several months – and a few
frightening hospital visits – before the woman finally recovered.
Most travellers think it won't happen to them.
Maybe they've been to the same spot several times and experienced no
problems, or maybe they've had friends go and come back without any
horror stories in tow.
"Everyone's banking on the fact that they're not
going to have any problems that could have been prevented," says Dr Bob
Kass, chief medical advisor of The Travel Doctor, a national travel
advisory service.
So just how big is the risk?
"The risk for hepatitis A in less developed
countries is between one in 50 and one in 300, depending on whether
you're staying in a backpacker or a five-star hotel," Kass says.
"The longer you go, the less stars in your
accommodation, the more rural you go and the more contact you have with
local people, the more risk you have," Hudson says.
That said, one of the biggest misconceptions
people hold is that staying in five-star accommodation negates health
risks. It lowers the risk, but certainly doesn't make it disappear. So
the fact that the THAG study found folk staying in luxury accommodation
to be less likely to be vaccinated is somewhat disconcerting, doctors
say.
"It's a false sense of security that you get,"
Kass says. He points to an experience of his own, a five-star trip to
Phuket where he and his family stayed comfortably (and safely) at an
international hotel..
"We went on a day trip on a boat and the kids were
swimming around the coral when someone flushed the toilet . . ." You
guessed it, there it went, right out into the sea where his children
were playing.
One patient he saw contracted typhoid while
staying at a luxury resort in Bali on a breezy five-day trip, most
likely at one of the beachside happy hours where mussels and oysters and
other worrisome goodies abound. Kass says that while he wouldn't have
recommended the typhoid vaccine for such a low risk itinerary, he would
have gone over the do's and don'ts of safe eating and drinking, so the
two weeks the woman spent in the infectious disease unit in hospital
could have been avoided.
Four or five-star hotels may not be as clean as
one might expect, says Dr Peter Demaio, medical director at Travel
Health Care in Burwood, Melbourne. Often the kitchen-hands are the
lowest paid of all the staff, he says, so you might be in a place where
the foyer is fantastic, but the food handlers might not be aware of
proper hygiene standards.
``People believe that better quality hotels make
them immune to these things, but unfortunately mosquitos don't care
whether you're staying at the Taj Mahal or the local pub,'' Demaio says.
``People also think if you're careful you'll be fine, but mosquitos
don't particularly differentiate between people who are very, very
careful and those who aren't either.
There's an inherent risk when you travel,
irrespective of where you're going or how careful you are.''
And when it comes to malaria, the potentially
fatal mosquito-borne illness so common in Africa and Southeast Asia,
that's especially true. The number of cases of malaria imported into
Australia fluctuates between 600 to 1200 a year, Hudson says, with 25 to
33 per cent of the cases being of the potentially fatal strand. On
average the number is usually between 700 to 900, according to Nicholas
Zwar, a professor of general practice at the University of New South
Wales. Papua New Guinea, the Solomon Islands, Vanuatu and Southeast Asia
are the most common places Australians contract the disease, and the
chances increase for travellers who stay overnight in rural areas, Zwar
says.
Anti-malarial pills like doxycycline and
chloroquine are some of the prevention methods most widely prescribed by
doctors, but the tablets are not always popular, especially among budget
travellers going away for long periods of time. The pills have a
reputation for side effects and can be somewhat expensive and
inconvenient since you've got to remember to take them every day.
They are between 90 and 93 per cent effective, so
even if they are being taken according to the instructions, a person
could still conceivably contract the illness. Not surprisingly, studies
show that most people who contract malaria were either not taking any
anti-malarial tablets at all, or not taking them correctly, meaning they
skipped a day or two here or there, or stopped taking them too soon,
Hudson says.
But there have been cases of people who did
everything they were supposed to do and still contracted malaria. ``We
as doctors can't assume that by giving someone a script for an
anti-malarial medication that they will in fact get the prescription
filled and take the medication as suggested,'' Kass says. Many people,
after hearing the negatives from other people and reading scary tales on
the internet, will not take anything, so it's essential they understand
the importance of doing everything possible to avoid exposure to
mosquitos altogether.
And it's equally important that they are aware of
the symptoms of malaria in case they should become ill, he says. ``No
one should ever die from malaria as long as they seek a diagnosis as
soon as possible by having two or three blood slides over 48 hours _ not
just one. Malaria is easily diagnosed, can be treated with the drugs
available and you do not have it for life, that is an urban myth,'' Kass
says.
The defining symptom of malaria is a violent
fever, and often shivering, abdominal cramps, nausea and other symptoms
that accompany fevers will be there as well. The fever might not last
too long, an hour or two, Schwartz says, before it settles. But with
malaria, unlike the flu, it will come back, usually in about 48 hours.
The key is getting to a doctor straightaway and
making sure the doctor knows you've been away. Hudson says there have
been cases where people have died within 24 hours of the first symptoms.
Other debilitating illnesses include dengue fever,
yellow fever, cholera and Japanese encephalitis. So what can you do to
reduce your chances of a bed-ridden stint?
Develop a plan and a schedule for your trip, for
starters, Demaio says. Decide where you're going and for how long,
because the vaccinations you'll need and the precautions you should take
can vary considerably, even within the same country, he says. Allow
plenty of time, but not too much either. Don't head to the doctor six
months in advance because things can change considerably in that amount
of time. Six weeks before you head off is ideal.
Many vaccinations take a few weeks before they
have any effect.
It's also worth seeing a travel medicine
specialist rather than just going to your GP. This can save time, as
they're more likely to stock most of the vaccines you'll need so you
won't have to fuss around going to the pharmacy and then coming back for
a second appointment. It can save money as prices for injections vary by
as much as 15 to 20 per cent and larger travel clinics may be able to
buy in bulk and get cheaper prices.
Travel medicine specialists also attend
conferences, subscribe to journals and databases, and generally have
access to more comprehensive and current information about specific
destinations.
Someone who specialises in travel medicine is also
more likely to consider details a GP might not have thought of _ for
instance, certain anti-malarial medications can cause disorienting side
effects. Maybe not a big issue for the average traveller, but for the
scuba diver? Not fun, Demaio says.
And don't forget the practical measures anyone can
take: things like bringing along gastro-intestinal kits and first-aid
kits, regularly applying mosquito repellant, wearing protective clothing
and drinking bottled water, to name a few.
The good news is that the more you travel the less
hassle you'll have to endure.
``A person who is well prepared and travels
regularly may require very little in the way of injections because
they're already up to date. Vaccinations against hepatitis A and B last
a long time if you get the boosters and typhoid lasts three years. If
they are going to a place where malaria is a problem that could be the
only thing they need, or they may just need a flu shot depending on
where they are going and the time of year,'' Hudson says.
But if trends continue the way they have in recent
years, many travellers will continue to put themselves at risk.
Przeslawski, for one, says chances are she won't
change her habits anytime soon.
``It's really not worth the cost time-wise or
convenience wise if I'm just going on a short trip, in terms of the
potential risk of getting some little bug that's probably going to clear
up on its own anyway,'' she says.
www.tmvc.com.au
www.vaccinations.com.au
www.travelhealth.com.au
www.cdc.gov/travel/
|